Singapore home buyers have a simple choice: take an** HDB loan** (fixed at 2.6%) or a bank loan, available with floating and fixed rate.
The HDB rate has been unchanged at 2.6% since 1999, set 0.1 percentage points above the CPF Ordinary Account (OA) interest rate of 2.5%. Bank loans, by contrast, move with market rates — usually 3-month compounded SORA + a spread.
With 20 years of SORA data now available (since its introduction in 2005), we can finally compare how both options have really performed.
The Long View: When Were Bank Loans Actually More Expensive?
The chart below tells the story clearly.
-
The red line shows the constant 2.6% HDB rate.
-
The green line tracks the 3-month compounded SORA + 0.5%, the realistic cost of a typical floating bank loan.
-
The blue line is the raw 3-month SORA itself.

Source: 3-months compounded SORA by MAS
Across the full 20-year period (2005 – 2025):
-
Bank loans were cheaper than HDB loans for 182 out of 240 months.
-
Only two periods saw bank rates exceed 2.6% — from 2005 to 2007, and again 2023 to 2024 during the global rate spike.
That means roughly 76% of the time, borrowers with bank loans enjoyed lower interest rates.
The Difference in Dollars: $70,000 Saved
Let’s put that in concrete terms.
If you borrowed S$500,000 in 2005 for 20 years, here’s what would have happened:
| Loan Type | Average Rate | Total Repaid (20 yrs) | Interest Paid | Difference |
|---|
| HDB Loan | Constant 2.6% | ≈ S$642,000 | ≈ S$142,000 | – |
| Bank Loan (3M SORA + 0.5%) | Variable (typically 1–2.5%) | ≈ S$572,000 | ≈ S$72,000 | ≈ S$70,000 less |
So while both loans have their merits, bank borrowers paid about S$70,000 less in total interest over the same 20-year period.
What About Fixed-Rate Bank Loans?
Even if you had chosen a fixed-rate bank loan instead of a floating one, the overall outcome would have been very similar. That’s because fixed-rate packages in Singapore are ultimately priced off the same SORA benchmark — the bank simply “locks in” a rate (for example, 2.00%, representing SORA plus a spread) for a limited period.
In other words, fixed-rate loans don’t operate in a different universe — they’re just temporary shields against short-term rate movements. Over a 20-year tenure, a borrower will typically refinance several times, so the long-term cost difference between fixed and floating packages is usually minimal. The main advantage of a fixed rate is short-term stability, not necessarily a lower total cost.
Why HDB Loans Still Make Sense — At First
HDB loans offer unbeatable convenience, especially for first-time BTO buyers:
That’s why it’s smart to start with an HDB loan when buying your first BTO flat.
It lets you secure your home safely while construction completes — often over 3–5 years.
Why Refinancing to a Bank Loan Is the Smarter Long-Term Move
Once you’ve collected your keys, your loan formally begins, and that’s the perfect time to refinance to a bank loan.
Here’s why:
-
Lower interest rate potential: Banks typically price at SORA + 0.5–0.8%, which historically stays below 2.6%.
-
Flexible packages: You can choose fixed, floating, or hybrid structures to match your financial comfort.
-
Refinancing promotions: Banks often offer legal subsidies or cash rebates to attract refinancers.
-
Compounding savings: Even a 0.5% difference on a 20-year loan can mean tens of thousands saved.
In short, HDB loans are a good starting point, but bank loans win the long game.
The Takeaway
Over the last 20 years, a borrower with a bank loan tied to 3-month SORA + 0.5% would have saved around S$70,000 versus staying with an HDB loan at 2.6%.
While past performance isn’t a guarantee of future rates, the data shows that refinancing after key collection can be one of the most impactful financial decisions a homeowner makes.